Meghan Markle’s new Netflix series, With Love, Meghan, continues to generate intense debate. While the show is currently charting in Netflix’s Top 10 worldwide, some critics are still labeling the eight-part special a disappointment.

It is Tina Brown that is getting it wrong.

Among the outspoken detractors is former Vanity Fair editor Tina Brown, who offered a sharply worded assessment. Brown suggested that Meghan’s series—focusing on positivity, lifestyle tips, and personal stories—clashes with the more “raw” cultural climate in the US, where informal YouTube personalities and irreverent podcasts dominate. In her newsletter Fresh Hell, Brown questioned whether the Duchess’s new venture would resonate in “Trump’s America,” describing the country’s pop culture environment as “foulmouthed and disheveled.”

Brown also revisited Meghan’s departure from the Royal Family, nicknamed “Megxit,” implying that the Duchess was too impatient to stay the course within the monarchy. “All Meghan had to do was stay quiet for a couple of years,” Brown wrote, suggesting that if Prince William ascended to Prince of Wales, more “global gigs and red carpet rollouts” would have come Meghan’s way. Instead, Brown believes Meghan and Prince Harry chose the allure of Netflix too hastily.

Critics in the UK tabloid press have seized upon Brown’s remarks, calling them a “takedown” of Meghan’s brand. The term “takedown” typically refers to pointed or scathing commentary that aims to undermine someone’s credibility or success. In this case, outlets describe Brown’s words as such because they harshly judge Meghan’s decisions—both her post-royal career path and her personal branding choices—while dismissing With Love, Meghan as the wrong show for the current cultural moment.

Reality Check: A Show Still in the Top 10 Despite Brown’s critique, With Love, Meghan has ranked in Netflix’s Top 10 globally since its debut. This suggests that the show has found a sizable audience, even if it’s not matching the blockbuster numbers of Harry & Meghan, the couple’s previous Netflix documentary. According to insider reports, many viewers remain curious about Meghan’s perspective on wellness, community outreach, and personal development—topics that form the backbone of the new series.

Why the Strong Language?

• High Expectations and Royal Spotlight: As a former senior royal, Meghan attracts both intense loyalty and equally intense criticism. Any new project she releases is scrutinized as part of the larger Sussex brand.
• Media Culture: In the UK in particular, the royal “soap opera” is a staple of tabloid coverage. Labeled “takedown” articles often attract clicks and conversation, meaning harsh critiques can be lucrative for media outlets.
• Tina Brown’s Background: Brown herself has long been an influential figure in media, known for sharp insights and blunt takes. Her candor resonates with an audience that expects unfiltered opinions—especially when it comes to the Royal Family.

In Summary Meghan Markle’s With Love, Meghan sits comfortably in Netflix’s Top 10 worldwide, suggesting a significant level of viewer interest. However, the polarizing effect of her public image—magnified by the ongoing fascination with “Megxit” and royal drama—has led to scathing critiques like Tina Brown’s. Whether one views Brown’s commentary as a legitimate “takedown” or just more royal gossip fodder, it’s clear that Meghan remains a powerful cultural force. Despite the mixed reviews, her latest foray into Netflix underscores her ongoing quest to define her own narrative—and, evidently, many people are still tuning in to watch.