A screenshot of Justin Baldoni’s newly launched website displaying legal documents and leaked text messages from Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively amid their ongoing lawsuit. The website is part of Baldoni’s PR strategy in the high-profile legal battle.

Justin Baldoni Counters Blake Lively’s Allegations: Key Insights

Justin Baldoni has launched a long-promised website to publicly counter Blake Lively’s allegations of sexual harassment and smear tactics, but the rollout has been underwhelming. Despite his claims of full transparency, the site primarily features his first amended complaint from his $400 million lawsuit against Lively and Ryan Reynolds, along with a text message timeline. While Baldoni’s team frames the timeline as crucial evidence, critics note that it lacks substantive new revelations.

One notable text exchange highlighted on the site is between Baldoni and Reynolds before filming It Ends With Us, in which Reynolds expresses excitement about Lively collaborating with Baldoni, calling him “dynamic” and saying he “adores” him. However, these texts predate any conflict, making them of questionable relevance to Baldoni’s claims that Lively later tried to destroy his career.

The website also includes metadata-related accusations against The New York Times, suggesting the newspaper had early access to Lively’s state civil rights complaint before publication. Baldoni’s team argues that this proves a coordinated smear campaign, but The Times has already denied these claims, explaining that the disputed date in their online source code was simply generated by Google’s software.

Baldoni’s lawsuit also takes an unexpected turn by reviving the bizarre claim that Marvel’s Deadpool & Wolverine mocked him with a character named “Nicepool.” His legal team initially demanded that Disney preserve all documents related to any harassment complaints against Reynolds—a move that fueled speculation but ultimately seems baseless, as no such complaints have surfaced.

Meanwhile, Lively and Reynolds’ legal team is pushing for two key actions at the upcoming February 3 hearing:

  1. Preventing Baldoni’s attorney, Bryan Freedman, from making more inflammatory public statements about the case.
  2. Blocking Freedman from deposing Lively in the lawsuit.

Baldoni’s side argues that new evidence proves Lively orchestrated a campaign of false accusations to tarnish his reputation, while her team maintains that Baldoni’s lawsuit is a retaliation attempt meant to silence her.

With tensions escalating, Monday’s hearing before Judge Lewis J. Liman will likely focus on whether Freedman’s media appearances have crossed ethical lines and whether Baldoni’s $400 million lawsuit has enough merit to proceed. While a full dismissal is unlikely at this stage, Lively’s team is expected to continue challenging the claims in court.

Below is a detailed thread of the receipts Baldoni claims he has: I can’t believe he let his lawyers publish this. the greateST SELF OWN.

https://thelawsuitinfo.com/downloads/timeline-of-relevant-events.pdf

Justin Baldoni’s defamation lawsuit against The New York Times has been met with a firm denial from the publication, which called his legal claims “rife with inaccuracies.” Baldoni accused The Times of obtaining and publishing details from Blake Lively’s state civil rights complaint before she had officially filed it, but the newspaper refuted this claim. According to The Times, the date in question—December 10, despite the complaint being filed later—was a Google-generated timestamp unrelated to when the newspaper received and posted the document.

Baldoni, 40, initially filed a $250 million defamation lawsuit against The Times in January 2025, alleging that the outlet helped spread Lively’s accusations against him before she formally filed court documents. Lively, 37, had accused Baldoni of sexual harassment, fostering a hostile work environment, and attempting to damage her reputation during the production of It Ends With Us, the film in which they co-starred and he directed. Baldoni denied all allegations and later filed an additional $400 million lawsuit against both Lively and her husband, Ryan Reynolds, claiming that she was trying to turn him into a real-life villain to distract from the backlash she received over her handling of the film’s promotion.

As the legal battle escalates, Lively has petitioned for a court-issued gag order to prevent Baldoni and his attorney, Bryan Freedman, from releasing text messages and behind-the-scenes videos from the film’s production. Lively’s legal team cited footage in which Baldoni is allegedly seen leaning in toward her, attempting to kiss her, rubbing his face and mouth against her neck, flicking her lip with his thumb, caressing her, and commenting on how good she smells—all while not in character.

Freedman dismissed Lively’s gag order request, calling it a desperate move to suppress the truth. He argued that Lively’s influence in Hollywood is built on fear of her powerful connections, particularly her husband, Ryan Reynolds, and their industry allies. In a statement, Freedman claimed that Lively had orchestrated a mass-distributed “hit piece” against Baldoni via The New York Times, attempting to paint herself as a victim while allegedly abusing her own power in Hollywood.

With The New York Times firmly denying Baldoni’s claims and reinforcing that its reporting was accurate, the legal battle is shaping up to be one of Hollywood’s most contentious feuds in recent years. As both sides dig in, the fight over public perception, career damage, and the right to control the narrative is only intensifying.

8 thoughts on “Justin Baldoni Counters Blake Lively’s Allegations: Key Insights

  1. Could you please interview Tim Flores, the father of Travis Flores, the author of the script ‘Three Feet distance’. Baldoni stole his script and make his movie ‘Five feet distance’ (even the title is so close and copied). Because Tim Flores says on his FB profile that the lawsuit was never settled and Travis died before any solution was found. Bryan Freedman was then Travis’ lawyer and then changed camp (and work for Baldoni now).

    Nobody is interviewing him or making a story about him and his son, or explain exactly what happen with the lawsuit and i think it would give great i sight on Baldoni’s real face. Claiming now that BL ‘stole’ his film.

    Tim Flores FB : https://m.facebook.com/tim.flores.79/

    His post about Baldoni :

    https://www.facebook.com/1386708063/posts/pfbid034T2kAkuv8b6qqssb4ZHbFGsyDM2HdwET7Z5psvQ297o19DQwSDsD2NynAytDZDvyl/?app=fbl

    Travis Flores’ lawsuit (13 pages worth reading) :

    https://www.bloomberglaw.com/public/desktop/document/TravisFloresvJustinBaldonietalDocketNo221cv07063CDCalSep012021Cou?doc_id=X236PTENOM39ONQ6EHMIOS6FUO8

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Also if you don’t know about them, there are 2 other lawuits against Baldoni :

    1. Baldoni and Wayfairer are silencing and keeping the right of the documentary of former NBA star Craig Hodges who was a Black activist and sadly silenced for that by the NBA. 2 articles :

    https://deadline.com/2024/09/craig-hodges-documentary-rights-battle-1236099439/

    https://delawarevalleyjournal.com/former-nba-star-and-civil-rights-activist-says-justin-baldoni-blocked-documentary/

    “Heath and Baldoni tried to convince Jivi Singh (the indian director chosen by Craig Hodges) he wasn’t the right man for the job due to his ethnicity”

    2) An ex-employee (african-american) of his podcast “Man enough” sued him in 2020 for discrimination and retaliation, and this was appatently settled in the end (name’s plaintiff is removed to respect his privacy) : 

    https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nCm30tIhp90pmuiwpza5Z6tUyuyyaD7M/view?usp=sharing

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment