Petty Kate: The Receipts Behind the Kindness

Every Christmas, the Princess of Wales celebrates love and empathy in Westminster Abbey. Her own sister-in-law has seen very little of either.

Every December, Catherine, Princess of Wales, fills Westminster Abbey with candlelight, carols and around 1,600 guests for her Together at Christmas carol service. The themes barely change from year to year: love, kindness, empathy, caring for one another. In 2024 the theme was love and empathy. In 2025 it was “love in all its forms.”

It’s a lovely tradition. It’s also a useful lens. Hold Kate’s public message up against the way she has treated her sister-in-law, Meghan, and the two simply don’t match.

Take this year’s. Kate’s sixth carol service, on December 11, will celebrate love, kindness and caring for one another. Kensington Palace says it will honour the people who help others “feel safe enough to reach out for help.”

Unless, it seems, you’re Meghan.

Safe enough to reach out?

In her 2021 interview with Oprah Winfrey, Meghan said that while she was pregnant with Archie, she had suicidal thoughts. She said she went to one of the most senior people in the institution, asked to go somewhere to get help, and was told it wouldn’t be good for the institution. When she turned to the palace’s HR department, she was told there was nothing they could do, because she wasn’t a paid employee.

To be clear, Meghan has never said she asked Kate. But Kate is hardly a bystander on this subject. In 2016, she launched Heads Together with William and Harry, a campaign to end the stigma around mental health, with Kate leading its work on children and young people. Getting people to speak up and ask for help is meant to be her territory.

So when her own sister-in-law said, in front of millions of viewers, that she had asked for help and been turned away, what did Kate say? Publicly, nothing. Not then, and not in the years since.

This December, Kate will honour the people who make others feel safe enough to reach out. It’s a worthy theme. It would ring truer if she had ever been seen to extend it to Meghan.

This isn’t just a palace script

Some critics wave the carol service away as something Kate’s staff put together and she merely turns up to. That isn’t quite right, and it matters. Kate has attached her own name and voice to these messages.

In 2021, she wrote a personal message for the programme and surprised TV viewers by accompanying singer Tom Walker on the piano. In 2024, she wrote a letter about love and empathy for every guest and read extracts from it in a voiceover for the broadcast. In 2025, she wrote another letter, handed to guests at the Abbey and at 15 community carol services across the UK, and the Christmas Eve broadcast featured her playing a piano duet with Princess Charlotte.

So this is her message, in her words. That makes it fair to ask whether she lives it.

The flower girl dresses

In November 2018, six months after Harry and Meghan’s wedding, the British press ran a story that would shape Meghan’s reputation for years: she had supposedly reduced Kate to tears in a row over flower girl dresses.

In March 2021, Meghan told Oprah Winfrey that “the reverse happened.” Kate had been upset about the dresses a few days before the wedding, and it was Meghan who ended up in tears. To her credit, Kate apologised, with flowers and a note.

Then comes the part that matters. Meghan said everyone inside the institution knew the story wasn’t true, and that she would have hoped Kate wanted it corrected. Instead, the false version stood for more than two years. To this day, Kate has never publicly addressed it.

Meghan herself suggested the palace may not have allowed Kate to speak up. Maybe so. But Kate is now the future queen, with her own communications office at Kensington Palace, and the silence has continued. A private apology is decent. Letting the woman you apologised to carry the public blame for your bad day is something else.

The small stuff

Harry’s 2023 memoir, Spare, fills in more of the picture, and it’s the small moments that are most revealing.

Before the four appeared together at the Royal Foundation Forum in 2018, Meghan forgot her lip gloss and asked to borrow Kate’s. Harry writes that Kate was “taken aback,” reluctantly pulled a tube from her handbag and, by his account, grimaced. Over lip gloss.

Harry also writes that Kate demanded an apology after Meghan, during a phone call about wedding rehearsal timings, put Kate’s forgetfulness down to “baby brain.” Kate had given birth to Prince Louis only weeks earlier.

In fairness, plenty of new mothers would bristle at a comment about their hormones, and on its own it would be nothing. But next to the lip gloss and the dresses, it paints a picture of someone keeping score from the very start.

2026: home, but not welcomed

In August 2026, Harry and Meghan moved back to Britain with Archie and Lilibet after six years in the United States. If ever there was a moment for the warmth of the carol service to show up in real life, this was it.

Instead, months later, the so-called Fab Four still haven’t reunited. William and Kate have noticeably stepped up their joint public appearances, and an unnamed insider told Vanity Fair this was deliberate: the couple want their roles kept “very clearly separate” from the Sussexes’. Anonymous claims deserve a pinch of salt, and Kensington Palace hasn’t commented. But nothing the Waleses have done in public contradicts it.

Christmas looks set to tell the same story. PEOPLE reports that Harry and Meghan aren’t expected to join the family at Sandringham. Instead, they’re planning their first Christmas in Britain since 2018 at their own home with Archie and Lilibet, and the magazine notes the rift with the wider family remains. On Remembrance Sunday, Harry made a solo appearance at a small market-town service while the rest of the family took part in the big official events.

For the first time since Kate’s carol service began in 2021, the Sussexes live in England. They have never attended one. Whether there’s a seat for them in the Abbey on December 11 will say more about Kate’s idea of kindness than any letter in the order of service.

Kate doesn’t need distance to protect her position, either. YouGov’s figures for the third quarter of 2026 put her net approval at +56, among the highest of any royal. She can afford to be generous. She simply hasn’t been.

What Kate’s defenders say

Kate’s supporters have real points, and they deserve a fair hearing:

  • Meghan said she took her request for help to a senior figure in the institution and to HR, not to Kate.
  • By Meghan’s own account, Kate apologised for the flower girl incident.
  • Royals traditionally don’t respond to press stories, whether true or false.
  • The Oprah interview and Spare made private family moments public. It’s understandable if Kate is wary of trusting the Sussexes again.
  • Most of the details above come from Harry and Meghan’s side. Kate has never given hers.
  • The Sussexes lived in California until this summer, so their absence from past carol services says little on its own.
  • Royal biographer Russell Myers argues the Waleses don’t see their work as a competition with the Sussexes and are simply focused on their own causes.

All fair. But none of it resolves the central contradiction. You can be wary and still be kind. You can protect your privacy and still correct a story you know hurt someone else. You can disagree with your brother-in-law’s book and still be seen to welcome his family home.

Kindness starts at home

Harry once called Kate “the sister I never had and always wanted.” That relationship is now unrecognisable, and the Sussexes have played their part in that. But Kate is the one who has made kindness her public brand.

On December 11, when she stands in Westminster Abbey to celebrate love, kindness and caring for one another, it’s worth asking who those words are really meant for. Kindness preached to 1,600 guests is easy. Kindness shown to the sister-in-law you’d rather avoid is the real test. So far, Kate hasn’t passed it.

Petty isn’t a crime. But it isn’t empathy either.

If you’re struggling, you don’t have to cope alone. In the UK, Samaritans are available 24/7 on 116 123. In the US, call or text 988.

Sources

  1. Royal Foundation – 2025 ‘Together at Christmas’ service celebrates love in all its forms
  2. The Nightly / CNN – 2024 carol service themed on love and empathy
  3. Marie Claire UK – Kate’s 2021 message in the carol service programme
  4. CBS News – Kate accompanies Tom Walker on piano (2021)
  5. Inverness Courier / PA – 2024 service, Kate’s letter and voiceover
  6. HELLO! – Kate’s 2025 letter to carol service guests
  7. HELLO! – Meghan tells Oprah she had suicidal thoughts and was refused help
  8. Fortune – Meghan’s account of asking palace HR for help
  9. Royal.uk – Launch of the Heads Together mental health campaign (2016)
  10. Good Morning America – Kate to lead Heads Together’s work on children and young people
  11. HuffPost Australia – the November 2018 ‘Meghan made Kate cry’ story
  12. NBC News – Meghan’s Oprah interview (March 2021)
  13. HuffPost – Meghan on hoping Kate would have wanted the story corrected
  14. Manila Bulletin / AFP – Meghan: everyone in the institution knew it wasn’t true
  15. Marie Claire – Spare: the lip gloss moment
  16. Yahoo News – Spare: Kate ‘grimaced’; ‘baby brain’ context
  17. IBTimes UK – Spare: Kate demanded an apology over ‘baby brain’
  18. IBTimes Australia – Waleses step up joint engagements; Vanity Fair insider; YouGov Q3 2026 (15 Oct 2026)
  19. HELLO! – the ‘Fab Four’ have yet to reunite since the Sussexes’ return
  20. HELLO! – how Kate and Harry’s relationship deteriorated
  21. PEOPLE – Erin Hill, “Kate Middleton Announces Return of Her Christmas Carol Concert and Reveals This Year’s Theme” (13 Nov 2026): 2026 date and theme, 2025 piano duet, Susse

Leave a Reply